Homemade Tomato Sauce from Frozen Garden Tomatoes

By Dr. Holly & Sebastian Waite · From our freezer meal day

A pot of homemade tomato sauce simmering on the stove next to a bag of frozen garden cherry tomatoes

100% gluten-free Corn-free friendly Freezer-friendly

Jump to the recipe   Free guide: all 9 freezer recipes

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. I only link things we use.

If canning tomatoes feels like too much, here is the easy way: freeze them whole. When you are ready, they go straight from the freezer into the pot and cook down into sauce.

These were Napa Chardonnay cherry tomatoes from our garden, plus a mix of heirloom and regular tomatoes from my mother-in-law. There is no rhyme or reason to which tomatoes I use. This sauce went into our gluten-free baked pasta, and it is naturally gluten-free and corn-free.

Watch me make it

This video starts right at the garden tomato sauce (2:33 in our freezer meal day video), so you can cook along.

Garden Tomato Sauce from our freezer meal day video. Press to play.Play: Garden Tomato Sauce (starts at 2:33)

Butter instead of sugar

Tomatoes are pretty acidic. Instead of reaching for sugar, I finish the sauce with grass-fed butter. It sounds weird, but in parts of northern Italy cooks traditionally use butter in tomato sauce instead of olive oil. It makes the sauce thick and glossy and helps balance out that acidity without adding any sugar.

I tasted it for honey and was ready to add half a teaspoon, but once the butter went in it did not need any. Our sauce has no added sugar at all.

Step-by-step photos

Pressed garlic cooking golden in avocado oil in a small black pan
Step 3. I cook the pressed garlic low and slow until it is golden, then add it oil and all.
I am adding dried herbs to the pot of tomato sauce on the stove
Step 4. Dried basil, oregano and a little sage. That is all the herbs it needs.
I am stirring my thick homemade tomato sauce in a black pot on the stove

Set Apart Kitchen · Sauces

Homemade Tomato Sauce from Frozen Garden Tomatoes

No canning needed: we freeze our garden tomatoes whole and cook them straight into sauce. Butter at the end thickens it and balances the acidity, so ours needed no sugar.

Diet
Gluten-free
Makes
≈8 cups, enough for 2 baking dishes of pasta

Ingredients

≈ means my estimate. I cook by feel, so taste as you go.

  • Whole tomatoes, frozen, any mix, ≈6 lb
  • Sea salt, to taste (we use Redmond Real Salt)
  • Olive oil, ≈2 Tbsp
  • Garlic, pressed, ≈6 cloves
  • Avocado oil, ≈2 Tbsp, for the garlic
  • Dried organic basil, ≈1 Tbsp (more if you have fresh from the garden)
  • Dried oregano, 1 to 1 1/2 tsp
  • Dried sage, a little (≈1/2 tsp)
  • Grass-fed butter, about 2 Tbsp

Tap an ingredient to check it off as you go.

Instructions

  1. Put the frozen tomatoes straight into a big pot. Salt them now; it helps pull out the extra moisture. Add the olive oil so the tomatoes do not burn on the bottom.
  2. Simmer and stir until the sauce cooks down and gets thick. This takes a while, because frozen tomatoes hold a lot of water.
  3. Meanwhile, press the garlic into a small pan with the avocado oil and cook it on low until it is golden brown. Do not let it burn. Add it to the sauce, oil and all. (Next time I would cook the garlic in the pot first, but if you forget like I did, this works fine.)
  4. Add the basil, oregano and sage, and salt to taste.
  5. Taste it. Finish with about 2 tablespoons of butter and let it melt in. Taste again before you add any honey; ours did not need it.

Tip. Freezing tomatoes whole is the easiest way we preserve them. Wash them, freeze them on a tray or straight in a bag, and cook them from frozen.

Recipe by Dr. Holly & Sebastian Waite · Set Apart Health · setaparthealth.comMade it? Tag us @setaparthealth

Free recipe guide

Get all 9 recipes from our freezer meal day

This garden tomato sauce is one of nine gluten-free recipes from the same afternoon of cooking. Our free guide has every one of them step by step, the order I cook them in, our gluten-free and corn-free swaps, and how we reheat each meal.

Download the free guide (PDF)

More from our freezer meal day

Everything below was made the same afternoon, and all of it is gluten-free.

We are Dr. Holly and Sebastian Waite. We cook gluten-free from scratch, grow a lot of our own food, and care for families at Set Apart Health, our chiropractic and family wellness practice in Mauldin, South Carolina. If you are new to chiropractic care, here is what to expect at your first visit.

Previous
Previous

Instant Pot Quinoa for the Freezer

Next
Next

Crispy Oven-Roasted Potatoes for Meal Prep